top of page
Search

A love letter to a genre: What is your favorite thing about cozy fantasy novels?

Nov 11
9 min read

 

Cozy fantasy has always existed, but lately it’s been used for new things – or maybe old things we haven’t seen in a long time. For a long time it seemed to be marketed only to children; now it’s marketed to more adults. The fantasy genre also seems to be making gestures to welcome more women readers, LGBTQ+ readers, and more diverse readers in general.


Most importantly, it’s taking on a more healing, comforting element. Times are hard and many of us need these nurturing spaces to rejuvenate us so we can go about our daily lives. For readers coping with illness and trauma, dark romances or thrillers might not invigorate with adrenaline so much as drain an overloaded nervous system. 


Cozy fantasy is no longer a tiny corner of urban fantasy that only appears in the fall. It’s become something greater, more literary, and more powerful than I’ve seen before in my lifetime. And I am captivated.

 

Is it the way it slows down fantasy stories and avoids violence, so you can bask in the wonderment of it all? 


Cozy fantasy plays with pacing on a scene level and a story-level.


Sarah Beth Durst says that one of the techniques she uses in cozy fantasy is slowing things down in the moments that, ordinarily, she’d spike the tension. This can be a pivot to the emotional stakes of the situation, a breathtaking description, a mystical encounter, or a humorous discovery.


One of my favorite cozy paranormal romances – and favorite books of all time – is Old Flames and New Fortunes by Sarah Hogle. This book’s pacing is beautiful. The first 2/3rds mirror the [], with ramping tension culminating in a car chase and a sex scene. But during the last third of the book, they take the time to fall in love. Much of this is arguably falling action – but it’s where the healing is, the cozy, the wonder. It’s lighter and more playful and gives them the chance to build a healthy romance. Usually, people have to turn to fanfiction for this phase of the story. I could not adore it more.


 [Sarah Beth Durst quote about 11]


Is it the largely guaranteed happy ending (HEA) borrowed from the romance genre? 


The guarantee of a happy ending changes the experience of reading any story. It undercuts a lot of the tension in ways that horror, thriller, and certain types of literary stories can’t make use of. While romance can be beautiful even when tragic, this is best done in the context of a bigger picture and not when the romance itself is the focus. 


Romance readers read for the vicarious delightful feelings of the characters falling in love. Those feelings matter as much as the tension does in horror and thriller, and too much tension would inhibit those feelings. The HEA is in place to preserve the delight and joy of the experience. 


Many readers have experienced failed romances of their own, or perhaps they haven’t seen many good examples of real romance. While it’s misogynistic to presume women can’t differentiate between toxic relationships on paper and real life, or that they’ll fall prey to toxic concepts they see represented in books, it’s also folly to think we stop learning from what we read as soon as we hit adulthood. Every person is different, and different stories help us process different things.


I have also heard the happier endings of cozy fantasy compared to how children's literature works, with an ultimate peaceful resolution and a sense of coming home. We talked about this a little bit at the All Peacemakers Needed Book Club[] recently.


Is it the way cozy fantasy welcomes women and LGBTQ+ into fantasy spaces?


Stories with male author can be notorious for excess sexualization of their female characters; often they give them a role to serve for the male characters in the story without much agency of their own. I have come across zero of these egregious descriptions or tossed-aside female characters so far the genre. 


The marketing of modern cozy fantasy books in general better suits the female gaze. Cute and whimsical covers with bright colors smatter throughout big box bookstore fantasy sections now. I want to dive more deeply into this idea: To what extent is cozy fantasy a feminist movement? To what extent is it the big five opening their doors to more women readers? The two things are not necessarily the same.


LGBTQ+ representation is abundant in this genre. The primary originator of the modern movement, many would agree, just might be The House in the Cerulean Sea by T. J. Klune. When I finally blog about this book, it will be a doozy. I used an Audible credit for the audiobook one bored summer day in 2021 and my lift changed forever. 


This story was unlike anything I had read before and despite the similar stories it has inspired, I still haven’t read anything quite like it. It’s something very literary and organic; the journey deep in Linus’s point of view, the corporate corruption juxtaposed against the realistically maniacal children, the way they pry your heart open inch by inch alongside Linus’s… The love story is one aspect of something larger and more encompassing, a shifting and expanding worldview. 


The opening of minds and hearts is at the core of modern cozy fantasy, or at least their adventure elements. Some journeys throw flaws into stark relief; these stories tend to cultivate self-acceptance with a delicacy like water gradually cooling instead of boiling. 


Here are just a few more examples of LGBTQ+ representation in cozy speculative fiction: 


In The Spellshop, the shop introduces Caz and Kiela to new friends who become like found family, The Pine Cone Coven. Some members are LGBTQ+. Often, however, these characters are the star of the show.


In the House in the Cerulean Sea, the subtle love story between Linus and Arthur accentuates the beautiful sense of found family between the magical children. Magical abilities have always served as a metaphor for many types of societal differentiations – nationality, race, intelligence, disability, attraction – and it aligns well with the missions of underrepresented voices.


Tomes and Tea series is also an example of LGBTQ+ representation combined with the emphasis on small business and community, exploring uniquely interesting consequences of tourism fame, and economic development.


In The Keeper of Magical Things by Julie Leong, [] and [] find acceptance and community in a small town, but they end up with both their own love and their big-city careers; as much as they love their rural time and the quiet that allows them to grow close, their current lives do not have to be sacrificed. This type of story is important and healing, too. In A Psalm for the Wild-Built, Dex goes by “they” for the entire story, and it’s never once confusing. 


It is potentially concerning how the overlap of the influx of women readers in fantasy and LGBTQ+ themes have coalesced. Is it the healthiest thing in the world that many women readers enjoy reading about gay men? No. It has the potential to make the gay men of the real world feel preyed upon and fetishized. How do we manage this? Why has this phenomenon occurred? Is it inherently predatory? This is a point of interest I will be discussing further at a later time. 


Is it the way cozy fantasy stories revere the natural world? 


The Reimagining of Thornwood House by Jaleigh Johnson, in which characters search for a near-extinct type of magical tree disguising itself amongst the rough-barked forest, is as much of a love letter to the natural world as I’ve ever seen. Evie feels a constant connection to magic; it’s so strong that when her homeland loses its magic and her connection is cut off, she goes in search of a new place to call home. 


I’m hard-pressed to think of a single cozy fantasy story that contains zero poetry capturing the beauty of a natural landscape. So far, I’ve blogged about some of these passages in Tusk Love by Thea Guanzon, Grim Tidings by B.K. Borison, and The Hocus Pocus Handbook by Ann Aguirre. 


Is it the anti-colonial representations of lost and obfuscated knowledge in cozy fantasy? 


In The Book Witch, book burners are the villains. When they succeed in burning down the world of a book, it disappears from history and memory. It’s a whimsical reflection of the very real brutality of the destruction of knowledge and modern censorship.


In The Spellshop, Kiela saves books from her burning library – and she has to find a way to survive on the island where she hides them. So she uses them, returning their charms and spells to the hands of the common folk of the island – and earning the respect and blessings of the island’s mystical protectors.


Somewhere Beyond the Sea, while much less cozy than The House in the Cerulean Sea, fixes some of its issues. T. J. Klune based the story’s boarding system on the boarding schools that native children were forced into during the colonization of North America, removing them from their tribes in a move of cultural – and literal – warfare. Readers felt he mishandled the topic and culturally appropriated a story that should be told by a native voice.

While that would be better, the representation vastly improves in Somewhere Beyond the Sea. The family and community combine to magic together a literal reclamation of the land and a safe haven for the formerly oppressed and divided magical people. I would like to hear more native opinions on it, but it certainly leaves a more hopeful impression.


On that note…


Is it the hope it evokes within you, helping you remember the things you wish for the most? 


Durst quote about ultimate and weaponized hope.]


While I’m not the biggest fan of “the dark night of the soul” story beat/trope, The Keeper of Magical Things uses it as a trampoline. The upward emotional propulsion is dizzying and glorious. It’s one of the most ingenious third acts I’ve found this year, unpredictable and uplifting at the same time.


“One of the things I love about writing fantasy and fantasy as literature is that when you close a fantasy book, it feels like the world is a little bit more magical than it was before,” says Sarah Beth Durst. 

 

Is it the emphasis on small businesses and supportive communities? 


Whether it’s Kiela and Caz’s Jam Shop (The Spellshop by Sarah Beth Durst) or [Legends and Lattes shop] (Legends and Lattes by Travis Baldree), cozy small-town spaces fill these books. I suspect they are particularly comforting and inspiring for those of us who live in and around small towns and hope for these communities ourselves. (May I brag that I do? The Magic of Books is in Seymour, Indiana.)


These economies are often close-knit enough to serve as ways of joining people together – and finding family.


I find particularly inspiring these portrayals of women finding financial independence–not just from any significant others involved but from any larger corporation. 


Is it the themes of found family, community, and home?


Cozy fantasy seems particularly focused on defining and redefining the nature of “home.” Often the characters come from troubled and tumultuous backgrounds – explained softly in their own words and actions – and create healing spaces for themselves and others.


The House Witch by Delemhach explores the nature of home and how it overlaps with community, country, love, and friendship; it explores how it still has the power to do all of those things even for people whose original homes were abusive. It demonstrates the defensive power of trauma and the power of survivors to build new lives and surpass all expectations in the name of a safe home.

 


 

Is it the humor?


Humor is a way of softening high-stakes moments in these stories. In stories designed to soothe tension in the reader, cutting the tension with the joke is a smart technique.


Several cozy fantasy books have had me, personally, in stitches. Lucy and Thalia in The House in the Cerulean Sea are fantastic comic relief. Old Flames and New Fortunes, a cozy paranormal, had me laughing out loud and reading off snippets like memes. Violet and Nathaniel's shop sign banter had me cracking up in Violet Thistlewaite is not a Villain Anymore.

 

 

 

Is it the cats with wings? The imagery as a whole?


The Spellshop, The Enchanted Greenhouse, Sea of Charms, The Keeper of Magical Things, and Cat Dragon all have winged cats. I’m sure this isn’t all of them. I adore. I was raised on Lisa Frank school supplies. Fight me.


Seriously, though – imagery is an important part of cozy fantasy. Visually, this includes:

Coffee and coffee shops

Tea and tea shops

Cats

Fairy imagery (small and fanciful versions of fairies)

Halloween-style imagery such as pumpkins, witch hats, and []

Comfort food, particularly baked goods


Imagery applies to all four senses, although no particular audial sensory descriptions seem common across the genre yet. In many cozy fantasy romances (dare I venture, cozy romances in general?), the love interests associate each other with pleasant scents. For example, []


This “imagery” area is a pitfall for the shortsighted. I’ve read cozy fantasy books where every cute little pixie or princely type was a good person, and the ugly ogres were bad people. This type of coding / metaphor aligns too well with racism and other forms of visual bias for my liking. Generally, cozy fantasy takes the opposite approach. [] Ogres find love in Legends and Lattes; a barbarian finds love in The Bookshop and the Barbarian; in The House in the Cerulean Sea, Chauncey finds acceptance and family love despite some foreign slimy qualities that initially cause people to fear him; 

 

Personally, I can’t choose. 


I love it all.

 

 

 

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


Join my mailing list

© 2023 by The Book Lover. Proudly created with Wix.com

  • Amazon
  • Slack
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • X
bottom of page