top of page
Search

The Modern Cozy Fantasy Movement and the Teacup System

29 minutes ago
4 min read

What is cozy fantasy? When I talk about this specialization, people have a lot of questions. As much as I adore it, it is difficult to define. Basically, I read The House in the Cerulean Sea by TJ Klune and my life was never the same. I had never encountered such a gentle, real-feeling, organic, slice-of-life story with so much whimsy and fantasy in it, especially not one for adults. And it could not possibly have been a story for kids considering the themes of workplace abuse and corporate corruption that pervades its background.


I was fascinated and I wanted more like it. Over time, I found stories like it: Legends & Lattes, The Tea Dragon Society, The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches, The Spellshop, and more. I even found cozy science fiction like Monk & Robot.


The Modern Cozy Fantasy Movement


Cozy fantasy has always existed, just not quite in this form. There were always children's stories like The Hobbit, seasonal paperbacks, and lighthearted swashbuckling fantasies marketed to men, often featuring buxom women with flowing locks of somehow-perfect hair.


As the genre has become more and more welcoming to women, LGBTQ+ folks, and other subcultures more likely to have experienced real violence, its literary and healing potential are coming to fruition. Cozy fantasy of the modern movement is written from adult perspectives for people experiencing trauma.


Mythology and folklore have always used fantastical metaphors to explain how confusing things like trauma work. The wonderment inherent in fantasy invites an enjoyment of life to resurface for those who have lost it.


No, I am far from alone in my craving for gentler, original fantasy stories for adults. We millennials, once raised on Lisa Frank and hope for easily survivable futures, are reaching ages where chronic pain and trauma grasp for more debilitating dominance over our lives. These stories are a balm for our souls.


Stakes and Violence in Cozy Fantasy


Stakes define the risks in the story. What do the characters care about? How do those things overlap with what is being threatened? How violent and personal are those threats? What are they trying to achieve and what will it require?


The stakes in cozy fantasy are often low or softened through time and distance. Threats linger in the backdrop and typically only rise in series that follow the same characters.


Cozy fantasy avoids, distances, and uses certain techniques to soften violence. The world as a whole can feel theoretical, boring, and low; personal violence can be a greater threat at times.


  1. Stakes are violent with intimate anguish and gore. 

  2. Stakes are violent; the stakes are high, including countries or ethnic groups.

  3. Violence occurs in the distance or using softening techniques; no blood or gore; the stakes might still include large groups of people

  4. Violence occurs off-page or stakes involve mild threats, but the primary stakes are emotional.

  5. The stakes are personal, emotional, and nonviolent.


Pacing in Cozy Fantasy


Pacing encapsulates the use of timing in a story. How quickly do the above stakes rise? How compelling is the story? How quickly does it feel like time is moving? How quickly does one event come after another? How often do the rules change?


  1. Breakneck pacing - events move along at a fast pace with rapidly rising stakes and rule changes.

  2. The story moves at a fast clip but the rules and stakes change less often.

  3. Trot pacing - the story moves from one scene to the next with plenty of transitional explanation; scenes contain plentiful description; the stakes rise gradually.

  4. The pace is gradual and slows when the stakes rise.

  5. The pace is compelling but prioritizes the journey, taking time for description, wonderment, and emotional development.


Healing Journey of the Characters in Cozy Fantasy


Any any good story, the characters go through an arc of change.


  1. The story is would realistically be more traumatic than healing. 

  2. There are healing journey elements but they are not cohesive.

  3. The healing journey is existent but weak.

  4. The healing journey involves no significant character change.  

  5. The healing journey of the character(s) is convincing and involves character growth and relevance to modern issues.


Soothing and Healing Literary Devices in Cozy Fantasy


One of the coolest things about cozy fantasy stories is that they're not just healing for the characters, but also for the readers. Reframing harsh circumstances in the light of wonder and humor can help us do the same in our own lives. These devices mirror grounding, healing techniques used in therapy.


  1.  The story uses literary devices to deliberately raise stakes instead of soften them. Adding personal dimension to stakes does not count; this applies more to manipulative tactics such as unnecessary portrayals of suffering. 

  2. The story uses more manipulative tactics than softening techniques. 

  3. The story uses one of the following to soften its highest stakes: humor, pacing, and quality descriptions

  4.  The story uses two out of three of the following: humor, pacing, and quality descriptions

  5.  The story uses humor and pacing to soften high stakes and high-quality descriptions to evoke wonderment


Imagery in Cozy Fantasy


This dovetails with healing literary devices in some ways, but not others. There are well known images associated with cozy stories: books, tea, cats, pumpkins. Some stories use these images to market themselves as cozy while the subject matter is dark and disturbing. Sometimes this still provides a degree of softening, but stories that put the cats in danger, for example, is probably not a cozy story at all.


Poetic descriptions help us pause, slow down, and think about the world around us the way the point-of-view characters do any time that happens.


  1. The story relies heavily on known cozy imagery but uses it in a manipulative way; for example, pets play a large role but they are at regular risk or get hurt.

  2. The coziness lies only in the imagery of a few known cozy fantasy tropes.

  3. The story has some of the manipulative elements above but sparingly.

  4. The story does not directly use cozy imagery to sharply contrast with violence or threats; they are implied but they are subtle and natural.  

  5. The story does not weaponize violence against animals or children; the imagery is uplifting and never excessively fearful.


When I evaluate using the teacup system, I will score in each category, add them up, and average them out to create the final score.


This is the first draft of something I hope to continue to evolve. Feedback is welcome!

 
 
 

Comments


Join my mailing list

© 2023 by The Book Lover. Proudly created with Wix.com

  • Amazon
  • Slack
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • X
bottom of page